Congrats on the upcoming wedding! We were married back in 2005 - but here's what we used. Though it looks like you've got a pretty darn good list going
Cocktail Hour Over the Rhine - My funny valentine
Over The Rhine - Lifelong Fling
Over the Rhine - Rhapsodie
Over the Rhine - Paul And Virginia
Over the Rhine - Etcetera Whatever
Over the Rhine - Like A Radio
Over the Rhine - Bothered
Over the Rhine - Drunkard's prayer
Over The Rhine - Anything At All
Over the Rhine - Hush now (Stella's Tarantella)
Over the Rhine - I Will Remember
Over the Rhine - The World Can Wait
Over The Rhine - Not Too Late
Over the Rhine - Spark
Over The Rhine - Ohio
Over the Rhine - I want you to be my love
Dinner Ben Folds - The Luckiest
Dave Matthews - Oh
Glen Phillips - Don't Need Anything
Eastmountainsouth - You Dance
Nickelcreek - Out Of The Woods
Jayhawks - All The Right Reasons
Wilco And Billy Bragg - California Stars
Jack Johnson - Better Together
Jamie Cullum - All at Sea
Toad the Wet Sprocket - All in All
Ewan And Nicole - Come What May
Badly Drawn Boy - The Shining
Glen Phillips - True
Wilco - I'm the Man Who Loves You
Dave Matthews Band - Best of What's Around
10,000 Maniacs - These Are Days
Backup CD (if first 2 run out) Original Broadway Cast Recording, Rent - Seasons of Love
Toad the Wet Sprocket - I Will Not Take These Things for Granted
Dave Matthews Band - Crush
Rufus Wainwright - Across the Universe
10,000 Maniacs - To Sir With Love
10,000 Maniacs - Peace Train
Beatles - All You Need Is Love
Coldplay - The Scientist
Over the Rhine - Anything At All
Beatles - In My Life