Hey, I'm here to represent the northeast Wisconsin sector of OtR fans. I sat through a long day's fest full of uninspiring bands just to hear this magnificent show at 11 pm. Here's the setlist as near as I can remember:
Long Lost Brother
Cruel and Pretty
I Want You to Be My Love
Born
Drunkard's Prayer
The Seahorse
Summertime (Porgy & Bess)
Hush Now
Lifelong Fling (not sure about the order of those last three)
Orphan Girl (Gillian Welch)
Latter Days
I might have forgotten one, but I don't think so. Anyway, they played as a "power trio" with Karin, Linford, and Devon on drums, which worked pretty well. They were definitely in a groove; their playing was tight but relaxed, the kind of ease you'd expect at the end of a tour. You could tell they were giving it their best despite not being sure at first whether anyone there had ever heard of them. "Lifelong Fling" was maybe the sexiest thing I've ever heard.
I'm not much of a reviewer, I just wanted to get this info up and say thanks to the band (if they read this) for coming to a new place and being a bright spot in a long and lonely summer.