QUOTE(the arkitech @ Aug 4 2005, 05:00 AM)
There's an interesting discussion of Crash here. For them who've
seen the film, does this affect your interpretation?
seen the film, does this affect your interpretation?
QUOTE(Trudes @ Aug 4 2005, 08:57 AM)
(((( possible spoilers )))))
Don,
Thanks for this link to the discussion.
I agree in part with what the critics were saying but I think maybe they were taking the movie a bit too specifically.
It was stated they thought the movie was quite unrealistic. I agree here.
Yes, the movie was made in Hollywood.
Yes, I think each character's situation was over-emphasized.
Unlike the movie, a lot of what we experience in real life is extremely subtle.
But, if the movie was all nuance, it might not have had the same impact.
One of the critics suggested the movie was to some folks the 'feel good' hit of the summer.
I very much disagree here.
I can't imagine feeling 'good' after seeing this film.
I think it was very thought provoking.
I think it dramatized the wrongness of our society.
I think it emphasized a white standard.
I think it emphasized a demoralizing frustration.
I think it emphasized a profiled mindset by many for many.
I think for me because all was a bit exaggerated (as Hollywood tends to do) it made me think about it more. As I stated before, it shoves it in your face and doesn't allow you to rationalize away uncomfortable realities.
I would like to hear other opinions about the movie.
One of my favorite lines from the movie:
Officer Ryan: "You think you know who you are? "
[Officer Hanson nods]
Officer Ryan: "You have no idea."
Don, have you seen the movie?
Don,
Thanks for this link to the discussion.
I agree in part with what the critics were saying but I think maybe they were taking the movie a bit too specifically.
It was stated they thought the movie was quite unrealistic. I agree here.
Yes, the movie was made in Hollywood.
Yes, I think each character's situation was over-emphasized.
Unlike the movie, a lot of what we experience in real life is extremely subtle.
But, if the movie was all nuance, it might not have had the same impact.
One of the critics suggested the movie was to some folks the 'feel good' hit of the summer.
I very much disagree here.
I can't imagine feeling 'good' after seeing this film.
I think it was very thought provoking.
I think it dramatized the wrongness of our society.
I think it emphasized a white standard.
I think it emphasized a demoralizing frustration.
I think it emphasized a profiled mindset by many for many.
I think for me because all was a bit exaggerated (as Hollywood tends to do) it made me think about it more. As I stated before, it shoves it in your face and doesn't allow you to rationalize away uncomfortable realities.
I would like to hear other opinions about the movie.
One of my favorite lines from the movie:
Officer Ryan: "You think you know who you are? "
[Officer Hanson nods]
Officer Ryan: "You have no idea."
Don, have you seen the movie?
